Re: El Nino, The 2023-2024 Winter, and You!
Posted: Fri Oct 20, 2023 3:18 pm
Also saw where NOAA dusted off their generic El Niño winter prediction maps
Ohio Valley Weather Observation & Discussion
https://absolutevorticity.com/
Very good posts on the MJo. Looks like the MJo is stuck in a phase 1 , phase 8 look This matches up nicely with what we should expect phase 1 and phase 8 to look respectively That explains pretty much what’s going to happen in the next week. Unfortunately this mjo wave will die out and not be a factor for a little bit. What I like is in my opinion this is a good indication of the influence the MJo could possibly have going into winter. If we could get a nice propagating strong mjo signal. What I don’t like is with a forecasted weakening El Niño Mjo waves are going to be hard to come by.
Yep on everything, particularly like the QBO status for the winter months.tron777 wrote: ↑Thu Oct 26, 2023 9:04 am The deeply -PDO should be no more this winter. I am expecting it to be in that weakly negative to neutral range instead of -2 like it was earlier. I believe that should help with more +PNA episodes this winter instead of a raging -PNA as we have been seeing thanks to La Nina. All in all though it is going to come down to the Arctic domain. If the blocking is there, this winter should be a good one. If it isn't, then it will no doubt be mild and probably wet too. We shall see! So far the blocking has been there and quite a bit too in 2023. Hopefully it continues. PV right now seems weak and elongated but it is just starting to develop and get its act together so the strength of the PV of course remains to be seen. I would assume a weak PV this year is on tap thanks to the descending QBO.
Definitely agree on a warm up. Then the question becomes do the tropics get involved to force another cool down or do we continue the warmth for a while? That issue remains to be seen.Bgoney wrote: ↑Thu Oct 26, 2023 9:42 amYep on everything, particularly like the QBO status for the winter months.tron777 wrote: ↑Thu Oct 26, 2023 9:04 am The deeply -PDO should be no more this winter. I am expecting it to be in that weakly negative to neutral range instead of -2 like it was earlier. I believe that should help with more +PNA episodes this winter instead of a raging -PNA as we have been seeing thanks to La Nina. All in all though it is going to come down to the Arctic domain. If the blocking is there, this winter should be a good one. If it isn't, then it will no doubt be mild and probably wet too. We shall see! So far the blocking has been there and quite a bit too in 2023. Hopefully it continues. PV right now seems weak and elongated but it is just starting to develop and get its act together so the strength of the PV of course remains to be seen. I would assume a weak PV this year is on tap thanks to the descending QBO.
Probably for a November thread , but after our cold spell the first week of November, ensembles are showing a west pac jet extension into the NW resulting in zonal flow and a fairly big warmup for all the lower 48 and a wet look for the western mountains
I agree about the warm up and that is normal for November. Getting snow in mountains and northern plains is nice during November. The one thing throwing me off is the possible tropical system in the second week of November. Has been a strange year imo but the waters are no doubt very warm so a development of a tropical system is possible but just not sure how far north it can really go. Hopefully it at least throws more moisture northward. I always mentioned I will not throw out a winter forecast but each year I can't help myself lol. I do have some thoughts and will always try to throw them out by mid-November. Les I have not forgot about the contest and that item will be thrown out on Halloween.tron777 wrote: ↑Thu Oct 26, 2023 10:28 amDefinitely agree on a warm up. Then the question becomes do the tropics get involved to force another cool down or do we continue the warmth for a while? That issue remains to be seen.Bgoney wrote: ↑Thu Oct 26, 2023 9:42 amYep on everything, particularly like the QBO status for the winter months.tron777 wrote: ↑Thu Oct 26, 2023 9:04 am The deeply -PDO should be no more this winter. I am expecting it to be in that weakly negative to neutral range instead of -2 like it was earlier. I believe that should help with more +PNA episodes this winter instead of a raging -PNA as we have been seeing thanks to La Nina. All in all though it is going to come down to the Arctic domain. If the blocking is there, this winter should be a good one. If it isn't, then it will no doubt be mild and probably wet too. We shall see! So far the blocking has been there and quite a bit too in 2023. Hopefully it continues. PV right now seems weak and elongated but it is just starting to develop and get its act together so the strength of the PV of course remains to be seen. I would assume a weak PV this year is on tap thanks to the descending QBO.
Probably for a November thread , but after our cold spell the first week of November, ensembles are showing a west pac jet extension into the NW resulting in zonal flow and a fairly big warmup for all the lower 48 and a wet look for the western mountains
All good Tim! You have until 10/31 at midnight to post your guess. Plenty of time.tpweather wrote: ↑Thu Oct 26, 2023 3:56 pmI agree about the warm up and that is normal for November. Getting snow in mountains and northern plains is nice during November. The one thing throwing me off is the possible tropical system in the second week of November. Has been a strange year imo but the waters are no doubt very warm so a development of a tropical system is possible but just not sure how far north it can really go. Hopefully it at least throws more moisture northward. I always mentioned I will not throw out a winter forecast but each year I can't help myself lol. I do have some thoughts and will always try to throw them out by mid-November. Les I have not forgot about the contest and that item will be thrown out on Halloween.tron777 wrote: ↑Thu Oct 26, 2023 10:28 amDefinitely agree on a warm up. Then the question becomes do the tropics get involved to force another cool down or do we continue the warmth for a while? That issue remains to be seen.Bgoney wrote: ↑Thu Oct 26, 2023 9:42 amYep on everything, particularly like the QBO status for the winter months.tron777 wrote: ↑Thu Oct 26, 2023 9:04 am The deeply -PDO should be no more this winter. I am expecting it to be in that weakly negative to neutral range instead of -2 like it was earlier. I believe that should help with more +PNA episodes this winter instead of a raging -PNA as we have been seeing thanks to La Nina. All in all though it is going to come down to the Arctic domain. If the blocking is there, this winter should be a good one. If it isn't, then it will no doubt be mild and probably wet too. We shall see! So far the blocking has been there and quite a bit too in 2023. Hopefully it continues. PV right now seems weak and elongated but it is just starting to develop and get its act together so the strength of the PV of course remains to be seen. I would assume a weak PV this year is on tap thanks to the descending QBO.
Probably for a November thread , but after our cold spell the first week of November, ensembles are showing a west pac jet extension into the NW resulting in zonal flow and a fairly big warmup for all the lower 48 and a wet look for the western mountains
Great Post Les. Never expected a strong El Nino and really moderate is pushing it for the entire winter. Sure you can have one month at moderate status but the remaining months could end up low end. Time will tell and the models have busted on this since last winter as it started out quickly but has steadied since then . I am still looking at what happens when we have 3 La Nina's followed by an El Nino. Those are interesting but again things have changed since these occurred so more info to factor in.tron777 wrote: ↑Thu Oct 26, 2023 4:45 pm Well folks... pet the chart below, it appears that for the month of October, Nino 3.4 is only going to avg around 1.6 degrees C above normal. Guess what the Euro had? +2.03 LOL! A huge bust from the Euro and all models really.
Nino 34.png
There is still a chance that this Nino can strengthen a tad like Nov of 1972. It did get over +2 for Super Nino status. But that year October was at +1.8 which is well above where we are right now. So I still say a super Nino is off the table. Moderate to perhaps low end strong is my call which impacts wise won't be much of a difference anyway.
Thanks Tim! The sample size is small since 1950 so we don't really have much too look at in regards to 3 La Ninas followed by an El Nino. This winter is going to be very interesting for sure with regards to what may happen. A lot of things we are discussing in this thread are favorable for cold and snow in the Eastern US but other things are not. I have said it numerous times that there are conflicting signals out there and I still feel that way even right now. The November runs over the next week or so on the seasonal models will be telling.tpweather wrote: ↑Fri Oct 27, 2023 4:16 pmGreat Post Les. Never expected a strong El Nino and really moderate is pushing it for the entire winter. Sure you can have one month at moderate status but the remaining months could end up low end. Time will tell and the models have busted on this since last winter as it started out quickly but has steadied since then . I am still looking at what happens when we have 3 La Nina's followed by an El Nino. Those are interesting but again things have changed since these occurred so more info to factor in.tron777 wrote: ↑Thu Oct 26, 2023 4:45 pm Well folks... pet the chart below, it appears that for the month of October, Nino 3.4 is only going to avg around 1.6 degrees C above normal. Guess what the Euro had? +2.03 LOL! A huge bust from the Euro and all models really.
Nino 34.png
There is still a chance that this Nino can strengthen a tad like Nov of 1972. It did get over +2 for Super Nino status. But that year October was at +1.8 which is well above where we are right now. So I still say a super Nino is off the table. Moderate to perhaps low end strong is my call which impacts wise won't be much of a difference anyway.
Lots of changes going on right now Tim with the PDO rise (although still negative just not as deeply negative as it once was). The IOD is lowering a bit now and the El Nino getting another WWB as we speak although I currently don't see it making the Nino much stronger then it already is. I still wonder if we have already peaked or does it hold on a little while longer before peaking. That part of the equation I am not certain about.
Hey Les and agree hard to say for sure if its peaked but imo it has peaked. Having a weaker El Nino imo tends to help us in the winter for folks that want cold and snow. Many other factors of course but a weaker El Nino tends to keep a really strong southeast ridge less likely. Does not mean we won't have bouts of the southeast ridge like this past week and of course not but they tend to be broken up because the stj is strong and moving along to help push it out to sea and troughs in the eastern part of the country tend to occur more often as well.tron777 wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 12:52 pmLots of changes going on right now Tim with the PDO rise (although still negative just not as deeply negative as it once was). The IOD is lowering a bit now and the El Nino getting another WWB as we speak although I currently don't see it making the Nino much stronger then it already is. I still wonder if we have already peaked or does it hold on a little while longer before peaking. That part of the equation I am not certain about.
I'm still not convinced either Tim if the atmosphere has fully coupled with the El Nino. I am still awaiting the STJ. We are still polar jet dominated which if that is the case come winter, that may not be a bad thing at all and could actually help us in the snow and cold dept. Again, we are in uncharted territory here with the current set up since there are low sample sizes when looking at past analogs. I'm very curious and interested in seeing where we go from here with November beginning next week. The November runs for the seasonal models will also be coming out next week and the week after next so that information will also be interesting to see.tpweather wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 12:59 pmHey Les and agree hard to say for sure if its peaked but imo it has peaked. Having a weaker El Nino imo tends to help us in the winter for folks that want cold and snow. Many other factors of course but a weaker El Nino tends to keep a really strong southeast ridge less likely. Does not mean we won't have bouts of the southeast ridge like this past week and of course not but they tend to be broken up because the stj is strong and moving along to help push it out to sea and troughs in the eastern part of the country tend to occur more often as well.tron777 wrote: ↑Sat Oct 28, 2023 12:52 pmLots of changes going on right now Tim with the PDO rise (although still negative just not as deeply negative as it once was). The IOD is lowering a bit now and the El Nino getting another WWB as we speak although I currently don't see it making the Nino much stronger then it already is. I still wonder if we have already peaked or does it hold on a little while longer before peaking. That part of the equation I am not certain about.
You should no doubt have a much better winter vs last year. The same should be true for us in the OV as well. It's going to be fun watching it pan out.